Self Contained Micro Cams
Self contained cams are very
popular now and getting better by the month. They offer a simple, all in one solution. No wires, no tapes,
just ease of use. The two cams below are in a class I call "micro cams".
There are more cams of this size out there, but these two seem to be the
most popular "Micros" at the moment.
They both easily fit in the palm of your hand - on my bike double
mounted for side by side testing.
Comparison chart
* Specifications taken
from mfg's website or product manual. |
Epic Stealth Wide |
Tachyon XC Micro |
Price |
$209.99 |
$129.99 |
Included
Accessories |
WP
housing, helmet , "elbow" and 2 contoured surface mounts |
Universal
helmet/goggle mount |
FOV |
168 degrees |
90 degrees |
Best video
setting |
640 x 480 @ 30
fps |
640 x 480 @ 30
fps |
File Type/codec |
AVI/MJPG |
AVI/MJPG |
weight w/battery |
2.5 oz (4.2 oz
w/WP housing) |
3.7
oz |
Battery /
included? |
AAA - Lithium
recommended / Yes |
AAA
- Lithium recommended / No |
Internal memory? |
No |
No |
Memory Storage |
2 to 4GB SD
cards |
4 to 32GB Micro SDHC cards |
Memory included |
2GB SD card |
No |
Still photos? |
Yes - several
options |
Yes
- in time lapse mode |
Digital zoom? |
Yes |
No |
Remote or LANC? |
No |
No |
Waterproof? |
Not without WP housing |
Yes - 34 feet |
Out of the box. Both cams are packaged very nicely
in minimal cardboard packaging without a lot of "fluff" so I would give them both
the green thumbs up for that. The Epic currently comes with more mounts than
the Tachyon. Both have cables to connect to your computer and Tachyon
has an additional cable to plug into your TV for viewing your video.
Cam set up and mounting. For testing or making my
own videos I often make my own mounts, as this seems to be a bit of a weak area
in the "sport cam" industry. For this test I made a side by side
platform and installed a ball joint from RAM mounts. This way I can
position the cameras in whatever orientation I wish. In this case, side
by side off the back of my mountain bike seat post. Additionally, the more SOLID you can mount a
camera, the more stable your video will be. Actually, I only run a
helmet mounted cam if I'm going to be doing a fair amount of panning
shots or need a detached camera.
Shooting video. The Tachyon has gone to
simple with a single button for on/record and off. This simple approach
I feel is great, it keeps you from accidentally being in the wrong mode
or erasing files etc. If you want to change the mode you will need to
open the back and flip a small switch. The Epic has two buttons
and has a fairly sophisticated range of options.
In both you really need to pay
attention and learn what each beep sound means. (I wish there were an
industry standard for record and stop, power on and power off beeps!).
Performance
|
Epic Wide |
Tachyon Micro |
Image Clarity |
fair |
very good |
Color quality |
fair |
very good |
Contrast |
fair |
good |
Lighting compensation |
fair (flicker is evident) |
good |
Smoothness of video |
fair |
very good |
Sound quality |
OK, but poor inside WP housing |
poor (waterproof
design) |
Mounting system |
good |
fair |
Battery life |
no data yet |
no data yet |
Epic Stealth Wide - Pro's:
-
Sleek compact design
-
Good mounting system with many options
-
Comes with batteries and memory card
-
Waterproof housing included (but lens scratches
easily)
-
Sophisticated menu and options (If you like that)
-
Wide 168 degree lens - if you like wide and don't
mind a bit of distortion
-
Light weight (out of the waterproof case)
Epic Stealth Wide - Con's:
-
Generally disappointing video image
-
Price is high for this quality of video
-
A little flimsy on the build side, like the battery
door compartment
-
4GB SD max memory storage? (needs to be verified)
-
Does not handle low light very well
-
Uses expensive disposable batteries
Tachyon XC Micro - Pro's:
-
Excellent video - color, contrast, smoothness,
sharpness etc.
-
The price is nice
-
Very rugged design (claims to be shock-proof)
-
Waterproof to 34 feet
-
EZ one button operation with LED verification
-
Large memory storage capability (up to 32GB)
-
90 degree field of view - just about right for all
around shooting
Tachyon XC Micro Con's:
-
Mounting system - only comes with one mount and that
mount makes it's size 15% bigger
-
Sound - basically unusable, granted it's a waterproof
cam as is
-
A little on the heavy side, but it's built TOUGH
-
Uses expensive disposable batteries
Bottom Line:
There are a few wishes for both cams but as far as the actual video goes
these two test videos pretty much tells all. Sunny bright conditions
example
HERE and cloudy overcast
example
HERE. This
HelmetCamReview shootout has a clear winner in my book: The Tachyon
XC Micro. It's superior video quality and great price will be sure to
sell many of these units. They just need to work on their mounting
system and they will have a real winner at a bargain price. Thumbs up
and good job Tachyon.
Tachyon XC Micro wish list:
-
Move LED indicator to front of camera, or add another
one.
-
Maybe a 120-130 degree model for close up action
(like surfing or sailing).
-
1/4 x 20 threaded mount, bar/tube mount and vented
helmet mount.
-
Rechargeable LiIon battery pack
Epic Stealth Wide wish list:
-
Improve overall video quality
-
Add record/standby LED to front of camera
-
1/4 x 20 threaded mount
-
Include spare plastic lens cover for waterproof
housing - or go to glass?
-
Rechargeable LiIon battery pack
Other notes and wishes:
One thing that happens with all these self contained cams (except
the VholdR cams
with their positive sliding switch) is that occasionally you are going
to miss video because you are in the wrong mode or the cam isn't even
on. If you mount the cam on your helmet or any distance away from your
own eyes you are dependant on hearing beeps or feeling buttons. On the
tests above I missed video with both cams and a bit more so with the
Epic (It's two button operation is more difficult when going by
feel/hearing). I would love to see a two way wireless (or wired, yes
wired) control button with LED, in other words a
LANC control.
This would allow remote positioning of the cam with a positive way to
make sure the cam is recording. Not a remote mind you, a remote cannot
tell you it the cam is actually on. You need something with feedback,
hence the LANC.
Threaded lens mount. The addition of threads on
the lens area would allow for addition of lens covers, wide angle lens
attachments and filters, or even another way to mount the camera.
External audio plug in. Wow, if one of these cam
companies could figure out a waterproof plug in for an external
microphone that would open up a lot of possibilities!
General notes about MOUNTING SYSTEMS
Almost all cams in this category have mounting issues, none is perfect.
I tend to make my own using RAM mounts. The exception is the vented
helmet mount, of which VholdR, Epic and others have gotten about right:
A snug mount on two adjustable straps. Before VholdR made theirs, I made
my own HERE. Don't be afraid to be
creative and make your own mounts! Remember YOUR point of view might me
a little more interesting!
Notes about AUDIO/SOUND
Even though I do not use much of my native audio from my cam shoots (I
usually put in music instead), it's a big bonus to have it. It adds to
the moment, a short chat at a break in the action with your friends or
whatever. A few of these companies have opted for water-proofness over
audio but I really hope they can find a way to do both! |